“On a dollar weighted basis hedge funds are a database-driven marketing gimmick.”

That quote was from my friend Eric Crittenden at Longboard way back in 2007.  We were chatting about how a lot of the investable hedge fund indexes massive underperform the more often quoted, but also uninvestable cousins.  I had just published an article for the Technical Analyst magazine that examined this chronic underperformance of the investable indexes.  How have the indexes held up since? 

 

Since March of 2003:

Investable Index:  0.98% per year

Non-Investable:  6.43% per year.

 

…and since our original conversation on email in 07:

Investable Index:  -2.62% per year

Non-Investable:  2.28% per year.

 

chart